This is a letter to the Marietta City Schools Board members in response to a 100k proposal to purchase Yondr pouches, which lock up high school student's cell phones from bell to bell. Our board members represent their constituents in their respective wards and the community is hoping we can find a better, more economical, solution and the board members will vote no to the ban.
My letter is a plea to empower our teens for the future as they enter a tech driven world and they can achieve digital literacy. Digital Literacy is defined by UNICEF, a United Nations agency that works to protect the rights of children around the world, as "the knowledge, skills, and attitudes that allow children to flourish and thrive in an increasingly global digital world." If our board members vote to lock up and take young adult's rights away to having 0% access all day, we are indeed doing a disservice to equipping them for the world and their future. It's staying digital, we are not going backwards. These students have to figure out how to balance computers and phones to graduate college and go into the workforce. If the skill is not learned on phones, they'll just be offsite all day on their school issued Chromebook, as many websites are still allowed on the server to browse. This is a training ground and if they are banned in high school, college is hardly the time to hand over a device when they are living alone and the stakes are higher. High school is the training ground for getting them workforce ready.
What has been lost in this very public media-seeking odd campaign, is the fact that we all have the same goal: to have a classroom with less distraction. Parents feel as though there are many different firewalls we can set up before we go locking up phones like this is a juvenile correctional facility. This is a detention placed on an entire school with the majority of the students compliant. Any behavior study you will research will tell you the most successful way to modify behavior is positive reinforcement, as it produces long lasting behavior changes through encouragement. Negative reinforcement punishes, restricts, gains compliance by producing anxiety. This data has existed longer than cell phones have been around. This school-wide ban to lock up phones is not just negative, it is overstepping into parenting and impacting our young adult's freedom. We want a cell phone rule that phones are to be off, silenced, and put away during instructional time. We want the phones taken up and consequences given if that is violated. Just like every other behavior. We have grown up with our kids skipping a recess, having a silent lunch, getting a zero, and accepting the consequences. We are asking the same thing once again, let's have a consequence when a rule is broken. Let's not punish the masses for the disobedience of a few. There are high achieving students that should not be punished when it is not an issue for them and are offended they are being treated like this.
Misrepresentation is also coming out against these young adults. Data is being shared that kids are "zombies", staying up til 3am scrolling, and "don't know how to communicate anymore." We are not talking about middle schoolers, we are talking about high schoolers and the 12th grade full of adult age children. Has anyone been around the 11th and 12th graders in the IB program? What about the 5 time State Champion Cross Country Team? Anyone seen the MHS Marching Band students at camp when it goes from 9am-9pm? Have you been to any Varsity sports team and seen the hours that these kids put in and so many even play in college? How about the kids dual enrolling in college starting in 10th grade? Did you know these kids can work at 14 years old and many hold part-time jobs? What about the students that have younger siblings and get them up, make their food, and drive them to school every morning because the parents both work full time? What about the ROTC kids that are going to enlist and serve our country? How about the kids that are literally moving out in just a few short months and will be in college for 4 years? The data is offensive to not only these families, but these young adults who don't have time to scroll. Look at their transcripts, look at their schedule, let's give them some freedom to their personal possessions that they deserve. Their schedules are busier than most adults I know. How would you feel if your phone was locked up during your daytime job with no access?
These young adults I mentioned above deserve the opportunity and freedom to continue to learn digital literacy for their future and find the balance. They are doing the work. They are giving the district awards and prestige. Parents are simply wanting a rule to be enforced, not a ban like this is prison. We also find that cell phones are often the least distracting thing being a student at Marietta High School. There are regular reports home to parents of fights, drugs, guns, and knives that are brought into the building. Those are the distractions we as taxpayers would like to see 100k go to ban from the building. Let's put those things in Yondr pouches instead and start protecting our future generation. Parents are blindsided never hearing reports of cellphones being so much of a problem that we need this punitive action. Here's the truth, our children don't feel safe in school anymore and parents don't trust the school. We had two horrific teachers last year in 9th grade and God forbid an emergency would have taken place on their watch. Those staff are gone now, but until we can have solid hires and safety measures in place, don't remove a lifeline. My family views phones as a safety call if needed, no one can predict a scenario that might play out in the event they could save a life with it. Not all adults are safe people and sometimes there isn't an adult present 24/7. My daughter called me last week as she was getting into her car with gunshots in the background from a neighborhood behind the school. She was out on a run for track practice and thank God had to leave early for a school dance. I was able to keep her calm and help her think on her feet to safety. No trusted adult was around because they were running. She sees her phone as a tool and protection and as a young female, I need her to have access to her device at all times if need be. 2 weeks ago, both of my 18 year old sons were in a horrible car accident and hit by a careless driver. The car was a total loss and he suffered a broken hand and injuries to the other hand, but thank God they both walked away okay. My son's cell phone detected the crash and on impact dialed 911. Emergency services were dispatched before he even got the car in park. My son sees his phone as safety and as a tool. What message are we sending to our youth if we are locking them up? On a personal note, some kids are carrying heavy personal loads inside their home. What is going on outside the classroom is the priority and that's the real world. When my husband was fighting Stage IV cancer and beat it, how comforting it was to send my kids a quick update reassuring them, "dad's doing great today", "chemo is over, labs look great!", "everything was negative, just letting you know!" This kept the anxiety down while having communication with the outside world.
To each family, my upmost respect for the rules you have in your home. We didn't have phones until the teenage years, but they are vital to them driving, working, participating in sports, applying to colleges, and learning to manage a phone throughout their young adulthood, personally and professionally. How I wish we could go back, get a landline, do away with them.... but we can't. It's 2025. Adults recognize the struggle, as most of you read this while you sit and scroll on your own device. Hypocritical in a way when the youth of this generation is having to work way harder than we did at their age. Ask a parent of a senior about college admissions requirements if you want to know how hard they are working. And let's recognize that for 7.5 hours there is some downtime during the day to check in on after school schedules, if their transportation has changed, have a normal outlet to communicate, and a way to get help if they needed to. Let's empower them, hold them accountable, and let freedom ring.... just not in the middle of instruction.